In the collection Counterintuitive facts
Do bacteria really outnumber the cells in your body?
The old 10:1 ratio is wrong. Current estimates put bacteria and human cells at roughly 1:1, with bacteria slightly ahead in a typical adult man, and the exact result depends on definitions.
AI-drafted from web search results, then checked by a second, independent AI that read 2 of its 3 cited pages in full and found the thread supported. No person has reviewed it.
The short answer
Slightly, but not by the margin often claimed. The popular figure of ten bacteria for every human cell has been replaced by an estimate of about 1.3 bacteria per human cell for a 70 kilogram reference man. That is the same order of magnitude, so the two populations are close to equal. Because the numbers are estimates, the answer is best read as roughly one to one. [1] [2]
Where the 10:1 figure came from
In 1972, biochemist Thomas Luckey estimated that each gram of feces held 100 billion bacteria and that the digestive system contained about one kilogram, giving about 100 trillion bacteria. In 1977, Savage's team set this against an estimated 10 trillion human cells, producing the 1:10 ratio. It spread because it was simple and vivid, and it is still taught. In 2014 microbiologist Judah Rosner pointed out that the 10 trillion human-cell figure first appeared in a 1970 book without proper citation. [2]
The 2016 recalculation
Ron Sender, Shai Fuchs and Ron Milo revisited the numbers in PLoS Biology. They used the colon, where most bacteria live, and found about 0.4 litres of content at roughly 0.9 times 10 to the 11th bacteria per gram, giving about 3.8 times 10 to the 13th bacteria. For human cells they drew on organ-by-organ data and found about 3.0 times 10 to the 13th, with red blood cells making up around 90 percent of the count. Their ratio was 1.3, with an uncertainty of 25 percent. For a reference woman the same table gives about 2.2 bacteria per human cell, because she has fewer human cells and a somewhat larger estimated colon content. [1]
The authors say the bacterial figure may be an upper limit, since bacterial concentration rises along the colon and stool density may overstate the average. Their total bacterial mass is about 0.2 kilograms. [1]
What counts as a cell, and what else lives in us
The ratio depends partly on definition. Sender and colleagues note that if only nucleated human cells are counted, leaving out red blood cells, the ratio comes out near 10:1. They treat red blood cells as genuine cells but acknowledge that others regard them as bags of hemoglobin, calling it a question of definition. Platelets are also debatable but matter little numerically. [1]
Sources also differ on the wider microbiome. An NCBI FAQ cites about 37 trillion human cells and about three times more bacterial cells than human ones, and says there is general agreement that viruses outnumber bacteria, perhaps by as much as 5 to 1, with fungi about ten-fold fewer than bacteria. Sorbonne Université reports that 2021 studies revised the virus estimate downward to a number comparable to bacteria. Both sources agree that, counting viruses and bacteria together, microbes outnumber human cells. [3] [2]
The balance also shifts over time. Sorbonne Université notes that after a bowel movement human cells are temporarily more numerous. [2]
Timeline
- 1972Thomas Luckey estimates about 100 trillion bacteria in the digestive system.
- 1977Savage's team sets this against 10 trillion human cells, producing the 1:10 ratio.
- 2014Judah Rosner notes the 10 trillion cell figure appeared in a 1970 book without citation.
- 2016Sender, Fuchs and Milo publish a recalculation in PLoS Biology, giving a ratio of 1.3.
- 2021Studies revise the virus estimate downward to a number comparable to bacteria.
Drawn from the dates given in this thread.
Sources
- Revised Estimates for the Number of Human and Bacteria Cells in the Body - PMC (pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) Found by source search. Not checked by a person.
- Is it true that there are more microbes than cells in the human body? | Sorbonne Université| Sorbonne université (sorbonne-universite.fr) Found by source search. Not checked by a person.
- FAQ: Human Microbiome - NCBI Bookshelf (ncbi.nlm.nih.gov) Found by source search. Not checked by a person.
Questions to follow next
- How many viruses live in the human body?
- Does the 1:1 ratio change the importance of the gut microbiome for health?
- How do researchers count cells in the human body?